Showing posts with label identity. Show all posts
Showing posts with label identity. Show all posts

Thursday, October 27, 2016

Life Society

In many ways, life is a series of transformation and personal growth – we see this in ourselves, in others, in laws, and in changing forms of society and culture. However, it is not often that a film is able to demonstrate these changes and their transforming power over a relatively short time span. Café Society, the most recent film by Woody Allen, is able to encapsulate these transformations over the course of a few short but vital years in the lives of the main character.

Set in the 1930s, the film begins with Bobby Dorfman, an eager young man from New York City who finds himself in an increasingly suffocating home, with two bickering parents, an opinionated older sister who is stuck in an unhappy marriage, a lecturing brother-in-law, and a gangster older brother. Wanting to experience the world for himself, Bobby travels to Hollywood and seeks out his successful film agency head uncle Phil Stern. Phil is a quintessential Hollywood executive, constantly working and engaging in social activities with the goal of creating more business opportunities. In essence, his life is a combination of working within self-serving relationships while also redefining himself to meet the image he feels he must portray in order to continue advancing in the industry.

Phil puts Bobby off for a while and eventually takes him on as an errand boy. He also arranges for his secretary, Vonnie, to show Bobby the town. With a new friend and a new job, Bobby begins to thrive, although he finds himself falling in love with Vonnie, who at the time has an unnamed love interest. However, when this relationship ends, Bobby and Vonnie became an item and Bobby – ever the New Yorker – makes plans for them to marry and move to Manhattan. By the time Bobby suggests this to Vonnie the audience already sees that, despite his inherent naiveté, Bobby has moved through important stages of life and is able to figure out a path to some success in Hollywood although he does not plan to pursue it.

Sadly for Bobby, Vonnie’s boyfriend was none other than Phil, and she decides to return to him and follow the path of the glamorous – yet seemingly fake – Hollywood wife. With his heart broken, Bobby returns to his parents’ home in New York. He goes through a variety of jobs without finding something fulfilling to hold his attention. In many ways, it is as if he has regressed to the pre-Hollywood Bobby, although with a harder and more jaded heart.

Finally, Bobby takes up an offer from his gangster brother Benny and joins him in operating a nightclub, Café Society, that eventually becomes the toast of the town. In a short time, Bobby grows into an adult who is capable of charming wealthy and influential patrons and balancing Benny’s less savory traits. He brings the experiences he gained while in Hollywood to Café Society and makes creates an image that goes beyond the naïvete he usually displays.

One night, Bobby meets Veronica, a high society divorcee who he instantly falls in love with. They share a whirlwind romance that culminates in marriage and the birth of a child. In many ways, Bobby seems to have come of age as a family man and as a businessman once Benny receives the death penalty for murder. Although Benny’s trial is quite visible, the aura surrounding it only added into the mystique of Café Society and business continues to grow just as Bobby does.

And then one night Vonnie and Phil walk into Café Society. All at once, adult Bobby seems to fade into the background and the young Bobby who moved to Hollywood re-emerged, complete with the vulnerabilities he tried to leave behind. At first he tries to hide from the spectre of his past but eventually Vonnie catches up to him and suggests that they get together to chat, with no expectation other than that. Over the course of several days, they tour the city and relive old times but at the same time highlight the ways in which each person has changed.

Vonnie has grown into the woman she claimed she never wanted to be – the wealthy but fake socialite who fills her time with meaningless stories and friends who flock to her because of her standing. Society views her differently than when she was a secretary however in her deepest heart she is unsatisfied and wonders what could have been if she stayed with Bobby. At the same time, Bobby has become hugely successful and has everything he thought he could want – a beautiful and loving wife, a growing family, and people who respect him. Society certainly views him in a different light than when he was an errand boy for Phil. In his heart, he feels the pain of his first love leaving him and yet is aware that the life he lives is likely more than he could have achieved if he and Vonnie stayed together.

Overall, Café Society takes the audience on a short yet intense journey through the lives of two young people who are trying to define what and who they are and demonstrates how the courses of lives differ from those planned. The film also notes how the people grow with and within society just as society can grow with and around them.

Thursday, March 10, 2016

Coming to Identity

Society uses ages of majority to define personal identity in many ways, for example the ages at which one can drive a car, vote, serve in the military, marry, and legally achieve majority and independence. These are all indicia of adulthood and coming of age. They are also benchmarks through which identity can be created – as member of society with full rights and privileges, a driver, a voter, a soldier, or a spouse. Combined, law creates a written system through which one comes to identity as well as age of majority.

The film Creed documents another phenomenon – an unwritten system of coming to identity – through the story of Adonis “Donny” Johnson’s evolution into Donny Creed.  The film begins with a young Donny fighting at a group home. Shortly afterward, a woman, Mary Anne, visits Donny and makes reference to his father. To Mary Anne’s surprise, Donny responds that he has no father. It soon becomes clear to the audience that Donny’s father was Apollo Creed, who died prior to Donny’s birth, and that his birth was the result of an extramarital affair. It also becomes apparent that Mary Anne is Apollo’s widow. To honor Apollo’s memory, Mary Anne takes Donny in and gives him a home – teaching him about his father while shunning the idea of him fighting.

The next scenes of the film show Donny as an adult – at least in terms of age – boxing in Tijuana and then working in a corporate position in Los Angeles. Although successful, he seems uncomfortable in his office, as if he is a child playing dress-up. In a bold move, Donny presents his boss with a letter of resignation, explaining that he feels the need to do something else. He then goes to the boxing gym he has been using – the gym affiliated with his father – and announces that he is ready to become a professional boxer. His trainer shuns this idea, belittling Donny’s achievements and denying the idea that Donny would be able to fight professionally – in essence, denying that he can live up to the family legacy. Despite the humiliation, Donny is undaunted. He tells Mary Anne about his plans and she is visibly upset, recalling that Apollo himself lost his life in the boxing ring. Still, he moves to Philadelphia to train.

The film then shows the audience a Philadelphia restaurant – Adrian’s – at the end of the evening. Inside, the walls are covered in photos. The restaurant is empty except for Donny, who is transfixed by one photo. As he stands staring at the photo Donny encounters the restaurant’s owner, Rocky Balboa. Rocky is taken aback when he is barraged with questions about the photo depicting the epic fight between Rocky and Apollo. Donny is at first reluctant to reveal his relationship to Apollo but ultimately does, shocking Rocky who, like the rest of the world, was unaware that Apollo had an illegitimate son. Donny asks Rocky to train him but Rocky refuses, arguing that Apollo would not want him to be a boxer.

Donny rents space at Rocky’s old gym and is persistent in his quest to have Rocky train him. Throughout all of this, Donny uses his mother’s last name – Johnson – and does not divulge his father’s identity to anyone. Eventually, Rocky stops by the gym. Rocky attracts attention, particularly from the gym’s owner, who wants Rocky to train his own son. Rocky politely declines and proceeds to work with Donny on an increasing basis, annoying the gym’s owner.  The gym’s owner soon proposes to Rocky that they set up a fight between Donny and his son. Knowing that the son is an advanced boxer, Rocky is reluctant to accept the offer. Donny, however, is insistent that they accept the offer and brashly believes that he can win. Rocky agrees but insists that Donny move in with him and begin training at another gym.

Donny is already comfortable in his apartment and has found a love interest in Bianca, his neighbor. However, for the sake of winning he agrees to move into a spare room in Rocky’s house, where he is surrounded by the history of Rocky, Apollo and boxing in general. Rocky’s training regimen is severe and “old school,” focusing on discipline and mental training as much as on physical training. At first, Donny fights some of these measures but ultimately he begins to thrive under them. As Donny Johnson, there is no expectation of him from anyone other than Rocky, and even then Rocky simply wants to see what Donny can do. Certainly, Donny wants to box because his father was a boxer and wants to live up to the image of his father that he has created in his own mind but his focus seems to be more on the winning aspects of his father’s legacy than anything else.

Before the fight, the gym owner tells Rocky that he’s done some digging and knows that Donny has “Creed blood.” Rocky explains Donny’s reticence to reveal his name and asks that this be kept quiet. Donny wins the fight. The next morning the secret is out – somehow, the sports media becomes aware that Donny is Apollo’s son. It is easy to see that Donny is conflicted over the revelation – it is no longer necessary to keep the secret, but now the world of boxing and the world in general views him differently. There is also a deeper personal question of who he is and what his next objective will be professionally and personally.

The latter question is answered when an offer comes to fight a well-known English boxer, Ricky Conlan. Rocky wants to decline the offer, realizing that Conlan simply wants to fight a Creed. This is confirmed when Conlan’s manager makes the fight contingent on Donny fighting as “Creed” rather than “Johnson.” The appeal of the fight is too much for Donny to resist. This is more than hubris, however. For the first time he embraces the idea that he is not only Apollo’s son but also that he can in fact live up to the family legacy. In the moment when he tells Rocky that he wants to take the fight – conditions and all – he begins the process of coming to and claiming his identity. While training, Donny is repeatedly overcome by doubts and is particularly offended when he is referred to as “Baby Creed.” When the time for the fight arrives he is visibly nervous and Conlan tries to play on this by taunting him about being born into a legacy he cannot live up to.

Mary Anne sends Donny a pair of boxing shorts with the same design as Apollo’s and both the Creed and Johnson names on them. This seems to encapsulate who and what he is fighting for. The fight is a brutal battle that goes the full 12 rounds against all expectations. Both fighters are bloodied and exhausted but in a contested vote Conlan is deemed the winner. Conlan’s attitude has visibly changed and he is respectful of Donny as a fighter, seeing past the association of being simply Apollo’s son. The crowd is equally accepting, chanting “Creed” in support of the underdog it jeered 12 rounds beforehand.

The film is not a traditional coming of age story – legally, Donny has already come of age. Rather, this is a coming to identity story, meaning that Donny goes through a variety of stages in order to claim his own identity and take possession of his name, with all that it represents. Throughout the film, Apollo is a constant figure – sometimes as an ideal to live up to and sometimes as a source of questions and lore. No matter the capacity, Apollo created a name and a legacy for himself and Donny is acutely aware of the weight that goes along with the name.

Donny’s initial choice to box as Donny Johnson was not an attempt to deny his father as much as to make a name on his own. This is admirable but masked the inner knowledge that he was indeed Apollo’s son and there would always be a legacy to live up to. Donny had to go through a variety of stages – akin to reaching various steps toward full majority – in order to claim his identity and reconcile his family legacy with his own. This could only be done after a series of tests – being revealed to the media, facing the unwanted attention of the Creed name, and fearing that he would not live up to the legacy created by the father he never knew, to say nothing of the actual fights themselves.  

This also required that he create his own family and support system out of people who did not seek him out because of his name and who saw him in the same light once they knew his name. Ultimately, Donny’s coming to identity required him to embrace who and what he was through his own aspirations. Once he realized that he could in fact live up to the family name and realized who he was as a person, notably during the fight, Donny came to his identity. It is through this unwritten process that we see the establishment of a person who is able to function fully for and as himself while understanding who and what he is.

Saturday, March 6, 2010

Legal Narratives of Identification - The Curious Case of Children's Storybooks

It should hardly come as any surprise that children's storybooks are rich sources of legal normativity and sources for legal analysis (see for example, the scholarship of Desmond Manderson and Shauna Van Praagh). In a previous posting, I touched upon the linkages between certain children's stories and their emphasis on breaking norms when doing so would be justified in order to stop a greater harm from being perpetrated.

In this post, I want to switch gears and address another series of considerations that have cropped up as I have been reading a host of children's books to my daughter. Given her rather young age, my spouse and I have devoted a considerable amount of time to reading my daughter books that emphasize identification and characterization as a central theme. A key example of this is the Usbourne "touchy-feely" picture book collection - particularly, the That's Not My Baby series. This series of picture books are aimed at developing the sensory and language awareness of infants and toddlers.

In these particular books, the narrative is a simple one, a little mouse goes out in search of a baby it identifies with and calls its own. With each baby it comes across, the mouse identifies something that a baby is wearing or possesses that distinguishes it from the baby it is searching for. Each item that is identified by text has a particular texture that the child who is being read the book can touch and associate with - e.g. "That's not my baby, her teddy [bear] is too fluffy"; "That's not my baby, her blanket is too silky"; "That's not my baby, her mittens are too fuzzy."

While the primary objective of this book (and others) as previously stated is to develop a child's sensory and language awareness, I argue that this development can have considerable implications later in life when we consider issues of identification of objects and people who are associated with such objects within the litigation process. These books help to train children to more acutely identify individuals and the objects they are wearing or possess, rather than simply latching on to more simple and base characterizations rooted in racial categories. When one looks to the sample pages of That's not my baby, one notes that the author, Fiona Watt avoids having the mouse identify the baby in question by skin colour, but looks to other identifying objects and/or textures that identify them as being distinguishable from the baby the mouse is searching for. This is not to suggest that identifying an individual's ethnic background is altogether invalid if coupled with other identifiable characteristics - however when race becomes the sole identifying feature, there may be a higher propensity for inaccurate identifications and worse, in the context of criminal prosecutions, such identifications may lead to wrongful convictions.

The need for greater accuracy in identifications was highlighted to me in one of the more poignant moments I experienced during my law school education. During criminal procedure, my professor wanted to sensitize the class to the fallibility of human perception with respect to witness identification and its ramifications on the rights of the accused. During one class, an individual who had been sitting amongst us for a certain duration of the lecture (but who was clearly someone no one likely recognized as part of our class prior to that day), got up and walked down the middle aisle that separates the classroom. The individual gave the professor a manila envelope, shook his hand, and then exited the classroom. From the time the individual stood up, walked to the front of the class and then left, roughly 10 to 15 seconds had probably elapsed. The envelope contained sheets of paper that were passed out to us. Each sheet contained a series of questions aimed at determining the extent of our ability to identify particular identifying features about this person, including their ethnic background, gender, what they were wearing, etc. The one thing we could all identify was that this person was African-American. Most correctly identified him as a male, although one or two didn't. As to this gentleman's other identifying features and details about what he was wearing, we were far from unanimous or correct.

This gentleman's experience with wrongful identifications was however far from academic. His name was Neil Miller. Some years prior, he had been wrongfully identified by a rape survivor and was convicted on the basis of her false identification which was also assisted with some improper influence by law enforcement. Thanks to subsequent DNA testing, Miller was freed but not before enduring several years of life in prison which took its toll on him.

Eyewitness and victim testimony are not going to go away, nor should they be expected to. But as my classroom experience perhaps demonstrates, misidentifying an individual can have serious ramifications on the liberty of another. Part of this is rooted in the poor training (if any) many of us have (including myself) in identifying critical details about others we may see rather quickly that move beyond the "basics" of race and gender (and in the case of the latter - at least one of my fellow colleagues in class identified Mr. Miller as a woman).

While identifying details may not come naturally to many of us, it can be cultivated. Perhaps by actively training individuals from a very young age to be observant and critical in their observations and maintain this skill into adulthood, we may be able to foster their capacities to provide more detailed and accurate identifications when called upon to do so.

It is worth noting that the development of this skill is not just relevant or important to individuals identifying suspects in a police line-up followed by testimony in court. It may be useful when a person is required to provide critical identifying information or characteristics in helping to find an abducted child or assisting law enforcement in tracking a wanted criminal.